>

>

The Tale of a City Within Another City

>

>

The Tale of a City Within Another City

>

>

The Tale of a City Within Another City

The Tale of a City Within Another City

Starting my day with Bun Maska and ending with Bhaat-Mangsho (staple Bengali dish, rice and chicken) — now I am proudly a soul with two cities.

Living between two worlds

Is this the dream I rebelled with my family to get?

It is so weird that we think, "A city fulfils your dreams," and not we ourselves. We give this city too much credit for our dreams, our hard work, our life. A city just living within India, that feels like a stretch and a sketch of the world. A city of and for everyone. Before coming to Mumbai, I thought I would make this fast-paced city my own in a slow fashion, but the possibility of it remaining just a thought is huge. And after coming to this town, I am certainly saying, "Ami ekla cholbo re!"

A girl from Kolkata with Bollywood fantasies, who does not dream of going to Mannat but of getting to her own Manzil, did not see the other aspects. From the time I landed in Mumbai, I felt it was Kolkata with the sea at its side. Just after leaving Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj Terminus, while I was heading towards Navi Mumbai, watching those old architectures, going through Atal Setu reminded me of Kolkata, building a familiarity in my mind. However, not so gradually, the city unveiled its horrors: sudden rain, light or heavy, being swindled by a cab driver, getting onto crowded local trains, and still getting late, getting sick often, not enough street food options, and getting overwhelmed by people always on the run. Life isn't fair, or so I thought!

In search of the serenity I was craving, I found Marine Drive as my best friend. Yes, once I got scammed, but once a cab uncle made sure I got home safely to my apartment like a guardian, as it was late at night. 'Bhalobashi', a word every Bengali says — it has become cringe because of the non-Bengalis — but whenever I watch my classmates say it, I feel it is kind of sweet. Maybe I was seeing through a black and white lens when it was grey.

This city made me more of a Bengali than I ever was. I got to know the grace in the art of solitude; I was used to being alone, but started enjoying it after coming here, and also, on the contrary, practised shying away from being shy. Sometimes I feel Vada Pav doesn't deserve the amount of dislike it gets.

Mumbai is like any other city, just fast. This might not be my dream, but the city is definitely making me work harder to get to it.

I rebelled with my parents for a smaller dream, but got a bigger dream to chase instead. Starting my day with Bun Maska and ending with Bhaat-Mangsho (staple Bengali dish, rice and chicken) — now I am proudly a soul with two cities.

By Aatmajaa Sarkar

About

Fitoor: an archive of art and human expression. Where stories come to life and writers find a community.

Follow us:

Related Post

Mar 22, 2026

...every story worth telling is written in the color of the pulse. Fitoor magazine's second edition, coming soon.

From us, to you

Dec 23, 2025

Presenting Fitoor, a place where anything is possible.

Marmalade Evenings

Dec 23, 2025

Photos and artwork that capture the imagination and reality of Mumbai!

Dec 23, 2025

To the city of restless delight

Where the old and the new, the slow and the fast, coexist

Dec 23, 2025

Ask any Mumbaikar, and you’ll hear the same truth: Bombay teaches you to move fast, and it teaches you to slow down — often at the very same time.

Dec 23, 2025

At forty-nine, when I think of Bombay, I don’t think of its chaos. I think of moments—the unexpected hand that steadied me, the stranger who shared an umbrella, the commuter who made a joke just when the day felt too heavy.The city never promised comfort. It only promised truth. It never pretended to be gentle. It simply kept showing up. And somewhere along the way, without realising it, I started showing up too.

Mar 22, 2026

...every story worth telling is written in the color of the pulse. Fitoor magazine's second edition, coming soon.

From us, to you

Dec 23, 2025

Presenting Fitoor, a place where anything is possible.

Marmalade Evenings

Dec 23, 2025

Photos and artwork that capture the imagination and reality of Mumbai!

Dec 23, 2025

To the city of restless delight

From us, to you
Marmalade Evenings

Stay updated with our letter

Join our newsletter to receive the latest insights, tips, and stories directly to your inbox weekly.

From us, to you
Marmalade Evenings

Stay updated with our letter

Join our newsletter to receive the latest insights, tips, and stories directly to your inbox weekly.

From us, to you
Marmalade Evenings

Stay updated with our letter

Join our newsletter to receive the latest insights, tips, and stories directly to your inbox weekly.

Behind every headline is a heartbeat. We gather the world’s stories from the sudden shifts in the wind to the quiet truths of our culture, to show how we are all connected in this vast, changing landscape.

© 2026 — Fitoor Magazine. All rights reserved.

Behind every headline is a heartbeat. We gather the world’s stories from the sudden shifts in the wind to the quiet truths of our culture, to show how we are all connected in this vast, changing landscape.

© 2026 — Fitoor Magazine. All rights reserved.

Behind every headline is a heartbeat. We gather the world’s stories from the sudden shifts in the wind to the quiet truths of our culture, to show how we are all connected in this vast, changing landscape.

© 2026 — Fitoor Magazine. All rights reserved.